Tuesday Tartare

Village Bar

A Glorious Facade
A Glorious Facade
Everything Everywhere
Everything Everywhere
Play you for an Ultra?
Play you for an Ultra?
I'm getting hungry editing this 😋
I'm getting hungry editing this 😋
The unassuming back
The unassuming back

Over the course of my years (yes, it’s been years now) as a Madisonian, I’ve wandered into a fair few restaurants, bars, coffee shops, and breweries. And while there are many I speak highly of, there are few I’ve ever made a habit of returning to. Village Bar is the exception. Perhaps my most visited establishment in Madison, it insists upon my regularity. If it’s been a long day at work, and I’m resigned to the fact I’m not making it to the gym, I decide I might as well stop for a burger and a beer on my way home. I always go alone and sit at the bar. I call it Gen-X maxxing. You know, getting away from the wife and kids.

Inside, you’ll find a masterclass in maximalist bar decor. Mostly signs for various beers and sports teams. But there’s always something new to notice, and something you wish were for sale. The walls are peppered with TVs, that’s a given. There’s nothing my ADHD-riddled brain loves more than watching Thursday Night Football and three different college basketball games at the same time.

You turn to the bar, the menu is posted above the large double-griddle. Please excuse the ultra enjoyers sitting in front of me, they must have lost a bet. Sometimes I bring a book if I feel like keeping to myself some loser ts, but there’s always someone who’ll try to make conversation if I don’t.

I’ve met bartenders from other bars, who themselves are regulars here, in case you needed convincing of this place’s eminence. I’ve overheard stories of those fortune tellers we used to make in elementary school being used for a strip game. I’ve heard about beautiful weddings, botched proposals. I’ve seen Brewers fans jump out of their shoes and Packers fans disavow Jordan Love for good (or until next week). None of this is unique for a local bar, but this is my local bar so in my life it is unique.

They’re most well-known for their brickburger, but I’ve tried all the cheeses and can confirm it doesn’t really matter. Pepper-jack has been my favorite recently. It always comes with a side of pickles and, optionally, raw or griddled onions. I wouldn’t call the burgers thick but they aren’t smashed either. I got a double one time and it was FAT. It’s a good old-fashioned burger; I don’t think it needs much elaboration. Never tried the non-burger offerings, and don’t expect to in the future. The fries have that double-fry batter coating that might as well be crack. It’s not that it’s the best burger and fries in Madison (it’s close), but going anywhere else means I’m not at Village Bar, which is an unsalvageable downside.

So if you’re ever driving home—in the pitch black despite it being before 6—and want to inject a little whimsy (and beer) into your night, you can always head to the end of Mineral Point Road. Sit at the bar, get called “honey” or “sweetie” by one of the lovely bartenders, talk baseball with some 70-year-old swing voter. Just please don’t talk to me if you see me.

Comments

    ← All reviews