Tuesday Tartare

Asador Bastian

The subterranean bar room
The subterranean bar room
Spider Crab Arroz Cremoso
Spider Crab Arroz Cremoso
Galiciana Steak
Galiciana Steak
Bone Marrow Potato Puree
Bone Marrow Potato Puree
Pistachio pastry and Basque cheesecake
Pistachio pastry and Basque cheesecake

Embarrassingly, I walked up and down West Erie Street in River North for a good five minutes before realizing the unmarked townhouse—adorned only by a discreet plaque beside the garden-level entrance, just enough to suggest it wasn’t someone’s home—in front of me was my destination. Asador Bastian has gotten a lot of buzz lately, featured by the New York Times and ranked 14th on the world’s best steakhouse list.

The Basque-style chophouse is the brainchild of Chef Doug Psaltis, whose Eat Well Hospitality group also runs the Greek-inspired Andros Taverna and the Italian spot Mano a Mano in Logan Square. Thankfully, they reserve space in the bar room for walk-ins like myself. I was ushered into the moody, subterranean space—a parlor-like room, now reimagined as a polished, intimate cocktail bar.

Naturally, the first thing on the menu that enticed me was the steak. But at Asador Bastian, you don’t pick a cut—you pick a cow. We passed on the Japanese and American options and chose the True Galiciana, a breed native to the Basque region and the pride of the house. From there, we let our waiter guide the meal.

We started with a beef tartare crowned with black truffle and foie gras—the truffle made the dish aromatic, while the foie gras gave it a smooth umami-filled texture. Alongside the first course came the tuna carpaccio, generously dressed in olive oil and chives. It was fresh and pleasant, though not a dish I’d rush to re-order. The final starter was the specialty Spider Crab Arroz Cremoso. Don’t mistake it for a paella just because it’s made with Spanish rice. It felt more closely related to seafood risotto, with a creamy texture, full of scallops, octopus, and crab. One order of this will run you 68 dollars (which in this recession economy is only about 5 eggs if you think about it), luckily, it was unbelievable. One of my favorite rice dishes ever.

Next came the Galiciana steak with a side of bone marrow mashed potato purée. People rave about the potatoes; I found them interesting but not transcendent— I couldn’t get out of my mind how much it felt like I was eating sour cream potato chips. The steak, though, was phenomenal. I definitely love a buttery wagyu, but this steak was the kind of dry-aged, deeply beefy, funk-kissed meat that defines a great steakhouse. Cooked just between rare and medium-rare, it was rich, savory, and primal in the best way. I gnawed on the bone when I had finished. For dessert, we tried a pistachio pastry and a burnt Basque cheesecake. Both were lovely. Neither changed my life.

Asador Bastian is undeniably pricey. The full experience is a major splurge or a special-occasion meal. But this restaurant delivers—and offers a far more intimate steakhouse vibe than the sprawling, clubby rooms of classic Chicago institutions. If you’re a fan of Bavette’s or the other Hogsalt group restaurants, and willing to trade a week or two of groceries for one dinner, you won’t regret doing it here.

Comments

    ← All reviews